data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ba4d7/ba4d7d4d7be26f5eb5662b3bb788fb4a6253253c" alt=""
Notice I said "suitable", and not "qualified". That's the only problem I have with Ellen becoming an "Idol" judge: she'd be the only one on the panel who doesn't have a professional background in the music business. All of the other three judges have worked as producers, with Kara also having extensive experience as a songwriter and a singer, and Randy as a studio and touring musician with countless music acts. Don't get me wrong ... I'm otherwise totally jazzed about Ellen being on "Idol" ... I'm just worried about how everyone else will accept her, particularly because of this notable lack of actual experience in the music industry.
Will she be funny? Of course. Will she know what she's talking about? As long as she sticks to what she knows and doesn't pretend to know more than she does (in other words, if she speaks from the perspective of a passionate music fan, and also provides feedback from her experience as a performer trying to entertain an audience), and I don't think we'll have to worry about Ellen coming off as fake. So ... bring on the new season of "Idol"!
I'm not so thrilled with this annoucement. After her judging attempt on SYTYCD last season (she just tried to be funny without real solid critiques of the dancers) I'm thinking that her schtick will become tired and annoying pretty quickly on Idol. If she actually sticks to her opinion on their performances and lays off the comedy it might be okay, time will tell.
ReplyDelete